11 Comments
User's avatar
Russell Hogg's avatar

As always Lorenzo gets me to look at the world in new ways.

Chris Coffman's avatar

Fascinating and compelling analysis.

Brettbaker's avatar

Cultural differences: In the 70s, a British criminalologist observed you were more likely to be stabbed in Britain, but more likely to be stabbed to death in the US.

gas station sushi's avatar

Where does gang violence in the U.S. get classified between instrumental (system 2) and reactive (system 1)?

Lorenzo Warby's avatar

Well, if you intentionally ambush someone, then that is instrumental violence. If it is a happenstance confrontation that turns deadly, that is reactive. A lot of gang violence is instrumental. Gang violence is, however, a relatively small proportion of homicides: though that can vary by time and place.

Gunther Heinz's avatar

Yes, and such is explained the difference between the USA and Brazil. In Brazil, there was never any MASTERLESS MEN. Everybody had a master, even the Master, and the goal in life was to always fool the master without the master knowing he was being fooled, even when it was the Master fooling himself.

Lorenzo Warby's avatar

Brazil is a country with a great future ahead of it, and always will be.

Gunther Heinz's avatar

And where the mice always blame the cheese.

Rather Curmudgeonly's avatar

Thomas Sowell has written about how black slaves cut loose from plantation culture would adopt Appalachian culture.

Lorenzo Warby's avatar

He has. I am a bit less sold on that as you can see equivalent patterns in non-slave groups.

SIM's avatar

Nathan Cofnas has a good article about that