Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Carter's avatar

Marxism is quite similar to psychoanalysis - the fundamental errors on which it is based lend it an infinitely flexible explanatory power, a sort of metaphysical divide by zero error. Marxism can explain anything, indeed it's followers frequently consider that to be its greatest strength. The problem is that in explaining everything, it explains nothing: since any outcome can be shown to be consistent with a Marxist analysis, it is unfalsifiable, therefore untestable, therefore from a scientific perspective utterly useless. However, from a social perspective, as a way of entraining minds via a sort of hypnotism, it is extraordinarily useful.

It's no accident that Freud and Marx were largely promoted by the same sorts of intellectuals throughout the twentieth century. Even long after economists had demonstrated Marx to be comprehensively wrong and psychologists had shown Freud to be a charlatan, their ideas retained a sacred currency within the circles of leftist intellectuals, because they are perfectly crafted tools for such types to attain power over the minds of men.

Expand full comment
Doctor Hammer's avatar

Great essay. I have frequently struggled to understand what people like in Marx. I finally accepted that it works like a young adult novel: lots of poorly thought out bits that are glossed over because the reader identifies with some feelings expressed.

I also particularly liked this paragraph:

"Faced with the take/make/trade choice to gain such resources, we often trade. Indeed, our propensity to trade (especially our propensity to share what we have acquired within a group: such sharing often being a form of trading across time) sets us apart from all our ape cousins."

Sharing as implied trading across time is a really strong insight. I recall Terry Pratchett writing of "storing food in other people" when one has more than one can consume. It really encompasses both why sharing is valuable, and why freeloading makes it break down so quickly.

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts