Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Chris Bond's avatar

I have to admit I grappled with your original "Consciousness and coherence" post and failed, so thank you for trying again.

Here, I still found your preamble slightly difficult to follow.

Maybe it's because I'm an engineer and the thought of having a theory unmoored from reality is more than a little terrifying in my context.

But from "Living organisms Let’s start with the concrete" this post is crystal clear to me.

I await part 2 with... interest.

Expand full comment
Tony Reardon's avatar

On dogs recognising themselves in a mirror. We (humans) are very visually oriented and we know that dogs have an amazingly better sense of smell and this is one of their primary ways of dealing with the world. If the mirror lacks all olfactory presence, then, for a dog, it can't be another dog never mind a version of itself. Very few dogs are interested in T.V. images.

Imagine claiming that humans are not conscious because they cannot recognise a some realistic reproduction of their own smell.

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts