11 Comments
User's avatar
Gunther Heinz's avatar

The Brazilian election offers up an interesting contrast. The system vast in size (over half a million voting machines used and over four million public servants drafted to work on a Sunday) is entirely centralized, entirely digitalized, leaves no physical ballots to audit, and was built for speed. It is a masterwork of automation. Yet, it is exactly this degree of technical complexity - of which the public has very little if no access to - that is invoked as evidence of its invulnerability to fraud. But all that´s needed, on account of its automation and technical perfection, is a handful of technicians at the very top, to generate whatever result is desired from the people responsible for running it. Now, from the very beginning (1992) the INSTITUTIONAL ASSUMPTION behind this whole monstrosity was that the people responsible for running it would never, ever, have some overriding interest in assuring that one election result prevails over another, much less could they count on the collaboration of the technicians who actually make it run. But this assumption HAS IMPLODED. So many of the judges who run it have been implicated in some of the most absurd corruption allegations imaginable. Certainly many of the career technicians involved, if not actually willing participants, know the risks of telling the truth nowadays. So it is even plausible that the election was fixed WITHOUT ANY PRIOR KNOWLEDGE ON THE PART OF THE SO-CALLED WINNER, Presidente Lula. This would probably be a first in human history.

ssri's avatar
Nov 1Edited

"The system ... is entirely centralized, entirely digitalized, leaves no physical ballots to audit, and ... is a masterwork of automation. Yet, it is exactly this degree of technical complexity ... that is invoked as evidence of its invulnerability to fraud."

With both real world and entertainment world descriptions of hacking, I find it difficult to believe anyone could seriously have accepted this "invulnearbility" argument. Especially one without a follow-up auditing capability.

Perhaps Lorenzo's comment here is applicable? "The failed analytical arrogance of such Theory has done much to create historically illiterate Western elites displaying remarkable levels of cognitive/epistemic closure. Hence we end up with institutionalised stupidity in Dietrich Boenhoffer’s sense of stupidity."

And from the Bonhoeffer "stupidity" reference: "Stupid people are dangerous and damaging because reasonable people find it difficult to imagine and understand unreasonable behavior. An intelligent person may understand the logic of a malicious person — his actions follow a pattern of rationality." I thus strongly suspect "malicious persons" are behind this.

ssri's avatar
Nov 1Edited

During my career in aerospace manufacturing and IT I came to recognize that "manufacturing" was essentially the application of informtion to the manipulation of materials to make the goods used directly or in support of providing services. This applied equally to the design parameters and to the process factors and criteria used on the factory floor.

Initially I was biased to believe that the "engineers" were the core source of valid and valuable information [i.e., the real value adders]. As I learned more about business and corporate behavior, I learned that many administrative functions were also needed to bring that engineering wonderfulness to full profitable fruition. Functions as as security, facilities, procurement, HR, legal, Health Dept., sales and marketing, etc., also played a role in rolling out a product to our market.

I gather from this essay you are suggesting the information contribution from those various functions, along with the those from the wider society (norms, laws), should have been factored into my thinking in this area. And that we should not forget those "mercantile" activities that do not involve much in the way of material manipulation, but still require substantial information management as part of their value in the marketplace: such as investment advice and services, legal services, insurance, much of medical services, real estate and other brokerage services, etc.

I will add I presume your discussion of strategy and risk assessment (as elements of information and knowledge - and wisdom?) also falls into the role of "management", the bug a boo of the Occupy Wallstreeters and many others, but a critical function that "someone" has to do (even if they are overpaid for doing so, as suitable analytical talent probably can be found in a much wider group of people than just those who make it to the top). Then again, actual pricing for those services suggests supply is limited compared to the demand.

I guess I would summarize your set of essays as a need for us to refocus "economics" as the older version previously called "political economy". [See also Jon Guze's comment. :-) ]

Lorenzo Warby's avatar

Management is one of those terms that can mean genuine coordination or it can mean layers of process. Hence economists prefer the term ‘entrepreneur’. One seeks the maximum level of productive coordination with minimal layers of management

Jon Guze's avatar

If not "capitalism," what collective term should we use for the system of politcal economy that we find in successful mercantile polities?

Lorenzo Warby's avatar

What is wrong with calling them mercantile societies?

The Wiley Dad's avatar

Well... that phrase can be easily confused with mercantilism which is different. (I guess that sort of depends on your target audience. Maybe its fine)

Or commercial society (you see Michael Magoon in https://frompovertytoprogress.substack.com/ use that a lot),

or market economy or exchange economy. Though it feels like I can think something being "left out" from almost any other near synonym

ssri's avatar

I join The Wiley Dad in feeling something has been left out. "Mercantile" can serve to broaden the outlook beyond simplistic capitalism, but "society" still (to my mind) comes up short in our usual understanding, as it remains silent on the set of norms and institutional contributors you also bring out in your essays. I would almost have to go to the word "civilizations" to capture that aspect of things, but that wording may not be truly suitable either. :-) [as overly broadening?]

Lorenzo Warby's avatar

One of the attractions of the term ‘capitalism’ is the sense of completeness, but it is a completeness that focuses on the wrong thing. If people used ‘capitalism’ to mean ‘a market economy with a threshold level of capital’ or even ‘a market economy with a threshold level of energy use’, I would be happier with it.

I tend to use ‘commercial society’ or ‘mercantile society’.

rebrannin@aol.com's avatar

I really like your identification of trust in communities. As a key to commercial success. We see ethnic dominated businesses in our neighborhoods (eg, nail salons, donut shops, motels) as being mutually supportive and successful. Virtue in America seems in very very short supply. You see how much this factor is left out of economics. Thanks 🙏

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Oct 31
Comment deleted