Great discussion and pulling all the threads together. There's another typo in the transcription of Marc Andreessen (great interview, I finally got around to listening to the whole thing) where he's referring to 'unrealised capital gains' (not 'capital games'). As someone living in Europe (Ireland) I am really starting to worry about the future and how we are going to get out of this hole our elites will not stop digging.
American living for several years in Wuhan, amateur but ardent student of Chinese history...and I think these are astute observations, explained very well, and the entire piece is nicely structured making it quite fun to read.
The interesting difference between ancient China and the West today is that there are plenty of easily observable counterparties available. If the Trumpian razor looks like having good effects a few years down the road European and Anglosphere countries will be tempted to follow. Although no other country has as strong an executive so the reform process will be much slower.
We in the US might hope our allies and "partners" get their act together sooner rather than later. I am still surprised we are seeing the lag or delays in Europe still in evidence, given the horror of govt abuses around the current "free speech" stances, the gargantuan waste on wind and solar (and killing existing nuclear capability), and the Rotherham situation and jihadi events being so prolific, etc.
But note that the US president is still only as strong as the other two branches let him be, presuming they are of the same party, etc., and even that is not a solid guarantee. "Live by the EO, die by the EO". While the executive branch was intended to enable "energy" and prompt responses when called for, it was still written during an age of 3 to 6 mph transport and communication. The current DOGE results are basically capturing the low hanging fruit, mostly in the discretionary part of the budget, and more subtle fraud is probably harder to discover. Plus we still need Congressional action to reform the big debt items of entitlements, civil service personnel rules, etc.
I don't think outright fraud is the main threat politically (or just plain waste). The major dynamic is that govt institutions and quasi-govt ones like academia & state-owned media have become "sheltered workshops" and "activist rookeries". Where people spend sinecured (and tenured) careers basically advancing their preferred ideology rather than doing their substantive job. Cue the humanities academic "researching" colonial theory or the "journalist" engaging in eg anti-Western propaganda instead of straight reporting.
Cleansing these would be like Hercules hosing out the stables-whose-name-I-don't-remember from Greek mythology.
The American Progressive movement has a deep and abiding disregard for the Constitution. Currently they aren't as overt as Wilson was, but the characteristic defines them nonetheless. Thus you see supposedly serious arguments that the bureaucracy isn't meant to be under the authority of the President, that clause of the Constitution be damned.
And they are now much more covert and slimey in what they have done to restrict and curtail the unitary executive role. So now we do need a strong executive to plug the "flow of resources" currently enacted or siphoned. But given the current reach of the federal government (here and often abroad), I also have reservations about letting that executive energy lose upon our modern world. Recall what Washington said about fire as a useful servant and a terrible master.
“Almost everything is a weak reed, compared to incentive structures.” is a restatement of one of the key economic laws that “incentives matter”. As Parkinson, Pournelle and many others have noted the incentives to bureaucrats are not to provide good efficient service to the citizens they are supposed to serve or the tax-payers that fund them (the sets of tax-payers and citizens overlap but are not at all identical)
One thing we can do is to ban the government sending money to NGO/charities/non-profits.
The government may want to buy goods and services from NGOs, but the goods-and-services end of the NGO needs to be set up as a regular for-profit company, which charges
the government money and pays taxes just like any other company the government outsources work to.
Another is to have much stiffer penalties for the abuse of political power, and for the soliciting of such abuse. Right now we pretty much operate as if when a corporation bribes an official, we sack the official or maybe give the official a small jail sentence all the while saying 'oh how terrible'. But the corporation? Ah, "boys will be boys" is still the attitude, even if they now need more gender-inclusive language. This leaves the incentive intact. What you want to do is imprison the bribe offerers, and give them fairly stiff sentences. And if that fails to have the desirable effect, you need to shut down the corporation altogether. Some NGOs need to be shut down as well, because they are beyond reform.
We may not be able to make them virtuous, but we can surely make them fear the appearance of vice.
Yes, from my days as a defense contractor employee, the govt does need contractors for many ordinary and quite a few specialized functions. And using contractors allows flexibility in net equivalent staffing levels, etc.
But there should be frequent and open competition for those contracts, with clear (and as specific as possible) requests for proposals, objective review of received proposals, and many reviews and audits during contract performance. These audits ought to follow the project mgmt criteria of measuring earned value metrics. These metrics usually include schedule milestones vs. money spent, but can and should also include steps in the delivery process vs. schedule and money. For example, definition of requirements, number of requirements met by the optimal design (need to get to 100%), test results vs. requirements, etc.
Proper incentives to obtain the next contract help, too. But when the bureaucrat and the contractor are in cahoots, then separate independent auditors are of course essential to surface fraud, nepotism, abuses, waste, etc.
I wanted to give an interpretation for S the model so that people did not think I was proposing the existence of surplus state wealth. After all S literally is accumulated surplus output, suggesting an accumulation of some physical thing. There is no evidence that S refers to some physical quantity.
So I gave it an interpretation as legitimacy to reflect its stabilizing function when it is positive.
Fair enough. As Xavier Marquez argues, the point is not that there is nothing there being referred to, it is there are alternative ways of formulating it that do not rely on uncheckable claims about what’s in people’s heads.
Absolutely, its a bit of a handwave, but the model seems to have some use, particularly in clarified how I think about these immiseration cycles.
Like I find your separation between inflation and price rises due the immiseration as a distinction without a difference in terms of the actual observation, the direction of the trend in a price series.
When population is rising and agricultural output is maxed out, the price of foodstuffs will go up. Townspeople will need more money to buy the same food they used to. That means they will try to charge more for their manufactured goods .so prices for nonagricultural output go up too. IF they cannot sell for higher prices, they cannot buy enough food to continue on in their business and the supply of such goods declines. Either way the price of manufactured goods will also rise because of food shortage.
Since more money is needed to for the same transactions, rising prices caused by immiseration would seem to create a demand for more money to pay the higher prices. This could be met through increased credit-money like bills of exchange, or through faster circulation of existing coins and bills.
Increased demand for more money ought to mean increased demand for coins. But this would boost the price of silver used for money, but the value of money relative to other stuff has gone down. So I couldn't figure how immiseration price rises can translate to increases in the supply of physical (silver) money, which is necessary for quantity-theory-of-money ideas to work, which they certainly seem to have later on.
When I was thinking about this like 9 years ago, I tried divided a region into local market subregions with their own supply demand relationships, with merchants moving from one to another place taking advantage of price differences, to try to figure out how a local famine here would stimulate silver production over there, but couldn't sort it all out in my head, so I put the whole thing on a shelf and went on to something else (it is a hobby after all).
No. I was an industrial scientist at, initially Upjohn, but after several mergers eventually Pfizer from 1988-2021. I worked in bioprocess development, but in both fermentation and isolation/purification to product the active drug substance. This would then go to formulation where it was made into the actual drug products (the pills, ointments, injections etc) that is sold in drug stores or used in hospitals/clinics.
Writing on this social science stuff is a hobby I began around 25 years ago and is now by retirement. When I wrote that the form has a spot for institution, Well Pfizer was my employer so I put that in. Didn't do that for my later papers, and now of course I have no institution. So Pfizer has nothing to do with it.
Application of Mathematical Models to English Secular Cycles
Michael Alexander
Pfizer Corporation
I must say that if Pfizer ever wants to bribe me for some reason they would be more likely to succeed by offering me interesting history papers rather than cash. :)
I created a Bluesky account after the elections in the US so I could gain insight into the woke bubble. It was an awful pit three months ago, and I abandoned it. Today, I checked it for the second time, and while it seemed impossible for it to get any worse, it is now infinitely and sincerely more deplorable. TDS, MDS, and all the -isms and -phobias are chanted like the enemies of the woke religion they belong to, as if these were their rituals for exorcising demons. If these guys win the next election, Biden's 4 years will look like good times.
Lorenzo, you may already have an account, but if not, you really need to set one up and check it out.
"Modern left-progressive politics has one aim, and one aim only: to insert the professional-managerial class into resources flows wherever possible." What a sly way of phrasing this!! :-)
So much more refined that "dipping their hands (or other body parts?) into a torrant of grift and graft!!"
"If we could find some systematic test of character—the role duels used to play—that would be great."
Maybe we can and should bring paint ball dueling back into vogue? Pepper spray? Rubber bullets? Loser submits to a permanent tatoo on his/her forehead that says "LOSER!!"
I have often heard the expression "tar and feather them" and "run them out of town on a rail", but I have never actually come across a credible historical mention that that form of punishment was ever actually performed - at least after say 1800??
Such a great piece and some great reading suggestions on China in particular. Take your point about the analogies to the
situation in the UK. I actually think reasserting Ministerial control on the UK system is technically far easier than in the US. This paper i cowrote for Policy Exchange sets out a plan. The question is the will - in a sense do our politicians actually have the will to power?
Wow, I thought my views on the the U.S. being overtaken by Imperial China and the culture of the examination system were sufficiently weird that I never expected to see anyone else express them.
Lorenzo is very good at connecting the dots (historical and modern) that many others miss.
We also need to remember that a reasonably open and free marketplace offers a rigorous profit and loss exam system all by itself in the private sector. This is further aided by wiser money lending and decent court enforcement and review of contracts.
If you were a Roman businessman who reinvested your profit to grow your business, what would happen to you? You would become a target for a Roman emperor to have you arrested and executed on trumped up charges and take your fortune to finance the state.
If you were a Chinese businessman, you had low status. You could spend your excess profits on growing your business to become a richer low status person or you could buy land and become a higher status landowner, or if you had a son with the aptitude you could invest in education for him in the hopes of becoming an even higher status mandarin.
Ditto for the Italian Renaissance merchants. They could invest their profits increasing capacity and driving down profits to the ruination of the trade, or they could use them to gain status as patrons of the arts, or to buy influence with the Church and local politicians, gaining status this way.
There was no reason to reinvest profits to accumulate capital until doing so became connected to status. In this post I argue that it was the introduction of gunpowder into the multistate European states system that ultimately led to capitalism and from that to the scientific revolution and cheap energy.
I would note that China was using large amounts of coal during the Middle Ages but did not industrialize. China was a single polity. There was no multistate system involved in frequent wars as in Europe and so no need to scale up military action and to resort to capitalism to pay for it.
Actually, Roman fortunes were generally rather safer than that. Political activity could make you are target, but there were plenty of multi-generational wealthy families.
You have to be careful about status. Merchants had notionally low status in Tokugawa Japan. It did not stop the creation of very long lasting merchant families and firms. Of course, one of the advantages of Japan was the daimyo were a form of competitive jurisdictions.
The China suffered somewhat from the curse of unity is clearly true. A recent study concluded that China was the most technologically dynamic in the period between the end of Han and the rise of Sui. A major part of the issue in China is that ruling Dynasties became suspicious of any connections that extended across regions.
Medieval European Christendom evolved in the way it did because of competitive jurisdictions and the suppression of kin groups.
The use of boycotts to protect those engaged in commerce was more common than people realise. The Hansaeatic League was partly organised to provide such mutual support. It was clearly, an important feature of caste systems.
It is much like the distinctions between legal and functional property rights: it is easy overstate the gulf between them.
The claim that DOGE is performing audits sounds very 1984 to me. In the case of USAID, they at most collected a few anecdotes and some of those weren't even USAID. I have yet to hear of anything close to an actual audit.
Great discussion and pulling all the threads together. There's another typo in the transcription of Marc Andreessen (great interview, I finally got around to listening to the whole thing) where he's referring to 'unrealised capital gains' (not 'capital games'). As someone living in Europe (Ireland) I am really starting to worry about the future and how we are going to get out of this hole our elites will not stop digging.
Fixed! Ta. And indeed.
American living for several years in Wuhan, amateur but ardent student of Chinese history...and I think these are astute observations, explained very well, and the entire piece is nicely structured making it quite fun to read.
Nice job, thanks much.
Thank you.
The interesting difference between ancient China and the West today is that there are plenty of easily observable counterparties available. If the Trumpian razor looks like having good effects a few years down the road European and Anglosphere countries will be tempted to follow. Although no other country has as strong an executive so the reform process will be much slower.
We in the US might hope our allies and "partners" get their act together sooner rather than later. I am still surprised we are seeing the lag or delays in Europe still in evidence, given the horror of govt abuses around the current "free speech" stances, the gargantuan waste on wind and solar (and killing existing nuclear capability), and the Rotherham situation and jihadi events being so prolific, etc.
But note that the US president is still only as strong as the other two branches let him be, presuming they are of the same party, etc., and even that is not a solid guarantee. "Live by the EO, die by the EO". While the executive branch was intended to enable "energy" and prompt responses when called for, it was still written during an age of 3 to 6 mph transport and communication. The current DOGE results are basically capturing the low hanging fruit, mostly in the discretionary part of the budget, and more subtle fraud is probably harder to discover. Plus we still need Congressional action to reform the big debt items of entitlements, civil service personnel rules, etc.
I don't think outright fraud is the main threat politically (or just plain waste). The major dynamic is that govt institutions and quasi-govt ones like academia & state-owned media have become "sheltered workshops" and "activist rookeries". Where people spend sinecured (and tenured) careers basically advancing their preferred ideology rather than doing their substantive job. Cue the humanities academic "researching" colonial theory or the "journalist" engaging in eg anti-Western propaganda instead of straight reporting.
Cleansing these would be like Hercules hosing out the stables-whose-name-I-don't-remember from Greek mythology.
(Augean! Yes, I cheated by looking it up).
"Section 1, Article II of the US Constitution"
The American Progressive movement has a deep and abiding disregard for the Constitution. Currently they aren't as overt as Wilson was, but the characteristic defines them nonetheless. Thus you see supposedly serious arguments that the bureaucracy isn't meant to be under the authority of the President, that clause of the Constitution be damned.
And they are now much more covert and slimey in what they have done to restrict and curtail the unitary executive role. So now we do need a strong executive to plug the "flow of resources" currently enacted or siphoned. But given the current reach of the federal government (here and often abroad), I also have reservations about letting that executive energy lose upon our modern world. Recall what Washington said about fire as a useful servant and a terrible master.
“Almost everything is a weak reed, compared to incentive structures.” is a restatement of one of the key economic laws that “incentives matter”. As Parkinson, Pournelle and many others have noted the incentives to bureaucrats are not to provide good efficient service to the citizens they are supposed to serve or the tax-payers that fund them (the sets of tax-payers and citizens overlap but are not at all identical)
1. typo 'weak reed' not 'week reed' (x2).
One thing we can do is to ban the government sending money to NGO/charities/non-profits.
The government may want to buy goods and services from NGOs, but the goods-and-services end of the NGO needs to be set up as a regular for-profit company, which charges
the government money and pays taxes just like any other company the government outsources work to.
Another is to have much stiffer penalties for the abuse of political power, and for the soliciting of such abuse. Right now we pretty much operate as if when a corporation bribes an official, we sack the official or maybe give the official a small jail sentence all the while saying 'oh how terrible'. But the corporation? Ah, "boys will be boys" is still the attitude, even if they now need more gender-inclusive language. This leaves the incentive intact. What you want to do is imprison the bribe offerers, and give them fairly stiff sentences. And if that fails to have the desirable effect, you need to shut down the corporation altogether. Some NGOs need to be shut down as well, because they are beyond reform.
We may not be able to make them virtuous, but we can surely make them fear the appearance of vice.
Yes, from my days as a defense contractor employee, the govt does need contractors for many ordinary and quite a few specialized functions. And using contractors allows flexibility in net equivalent staffing levels, etc.
But there should be frequent and open competition for those contracts, with clear (and as specific as possible) requests for proposals, objective review of received proposals, and many reviews and audits during contract performance. These audits ought to follow the project mgmt criteria of measuring earned value metrics. These metrics usually include schedule milestones vs. money spent, but can and should also include steps in the delivery process vs. schedule and money. For example, definition of requirements, number of requirements met by the optimal design (need to get to 100%), test results vs. requirements, etc.
Proper incentives to obtain the next contract help, too. But when the bureaucrat and the contractor are in cahoots, then separate independent auditors are of course essential to surface fraud, nepotism, abuses, waste, etc.
Fixed the typos, ta, and quite so.
Cycles like those in dynastic China (secular cycles) are also present in Western countries. Here is a paper I wrote in the English cycles.
https://escholarship.org/uc/item/230872k1
Am enjoying your paper. I am not fond of using the concept of legitimacy as an analytical tool. For the reasons discussed here: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1111/1467-9248.12202
I wanted to give an interpretation for S the model so that people did not think I was proposing the existence of surplus state wealth. After all S literally is accumulated surplus output, suggesting an accumulation of some physical thing. There is no evidence that S refers to some physical quantity.
So I gave it an interpretation as legitimacy to reflect its stabilizing function when it is positive.
Fair enough. As Xavier Marquez argues, the point is not that there is nothing there being referred to, it is there are alternative ways of formulating it that do not rely on uncheckable claims about what’s in people’s heads.
Absolutely, its a bit of a handwave, but the model seems to have some use, particularly in clarified how I think about these immiseration cycles.
Like I find your separation between inflation and price rises due the immiseration as a distinction without a difference in terms of the actual observation, the direction of the trend in a price series.
When population is rising and agricultural output is maxed out, the price of foodstuffs will go up. Townspeople will need more money to buy the same food they used to. That means they will try to charge more for their manufactured goods .so prices for nonagricultural output go up too. IF they cannot sell for higher prices, they cannot buy enough food to continue on in their business and the supply of such goods declines. Either way the price of manufactured goods will also rise because of food shortage.
Since more money is needed to for the same transactions, rising prices caused by immiseration would seem to create a demand for more money to pay the higher prices. This could be met through increased credit-money like bills of exchange, or through faster circulation of existing coins and bills.
Increased demand for more money ought to mean increased demand for coins. But this would boost the price of silver used for money, but the value of money relative to other stuff has gone down. So I couldn't figure how immiseration price rises can translate to increases in the supply of physical (silver) money, which is necessary for quantity-theory-of-money ideas to work, which they certainly seem to have later on.
When I was thinking about this like 9 years ago, I tried divided a region into local market subregions with their own supply demand relationships, with merchants moving from one to another place taking advantage of price differences, to try to figure out how a local famine here would stimulate silver production over there, but couldn't sort it all out in my head, so I put the whole thing on a shelf and went on to something else (it is a hobby after all).
I have started reading your paper, ta. I did a post on Fischer’s book, which I found to be somewhat confused.
https://www.lorenzofromoz.net/p/immiseration-cycles-and-monetary
Pfizer corporation has a history scholarship section?
No. I was an industrial scientist at, initially Upjohn, but after several mergers eventually Pfizer from 1988-2021. I worked in bioprocess development, but in both fermentation and isolation/purification to product the active drug substance. This would then go to formulation where it was made into the actual drug products (the pills, ointments, injections etc) that is sold in drug stores or used in hospitals/clinics.
Writing on this social science stuff is a hobby I began around 25 years ago and is now by retirement. When I wrote that the form has a spot for institution, Well Pfizer was my employer so I put that in. Didn't do that for my later papers, and now of course I have no institution. So Pfizer has nothing to do with it.
Thank you for the paper. That was a very interesting read. Monastical orders as a solution to elite-overproduction, hmmm.
Careful, though, or we will end up with an excess of Gregor Mendels!! :-)
I am clearly missing something, what is the connection?
Application of Mathematical Models to English Secular Cycles
Michael Alexander
Pfizer Corporation
I must say that if Pfizer ever wants to bribe me for some reason they would be more likely to succeed by offering me interesting history papers rather than cash. :)
I am so used to ignoring affiliations, I didn’t notice. (I like to look at the arguments directly.)
Great comparison. I hope DOGE will make progress.
I created a Bluesky account after the elections in the US so I could gain insight into the woke bubble. It was an awful pit three months ago, and I abandoned it. Today, I checked it for the second time, and while it seemed impossible for it to get any worse, it is now infinitely and sincerely more deplorable. TDS, MDS, and all the -isms and -phobias are chanted like the enemies of the woke religion they belong to, as if these were their rituals for exorcising demons. If these guys win the next election, Biden's 4 years will look like good times.
Lorenzo, you may already have an account, but if not, you really need to set one up and check it out.
"Modern left-progressive politics has one aim, and one aim only: to insert the professional-managerial class into resources flows wherever possible." What a sly way of phrasing this!! :-)
So much more refined that "dipping their hands (or other body parts?) into a torrant of grift and graft!!"
"If we could find some systematic test of character—the role duels used to play—that would be great."
Maybe we can and should bring paint ball dueling back into vogue? Pepper spray? Rubber bullets? Loser submits to a permanent tatoo on his/her forehead that says "LOSER!!"
I have often heard the expression "tar and feather them" and "run them out of town on a rail", but I have never actually come across a credible historical mention that that form of punishment was ever actually performed - at least after say 1800??
Such a great piece and some great reading suggestions on China in particular. Take your point about the analogies to the
situation in the UK. I actually think reasserting Ministerial control on the UK system is technically far easier than in the US. This paper i cowrote for Policy Exchange sets out a plan. The question is the will - in a sense do our politicians actually have the will to power?
https://policyexchange.org.uk/publication/getting-a-grip-on-the-system-2/
Wow, I thought my views on the the U.S. being overtaken by Imperial China and the culture of the examination system were sufficiently weird that I never expected to see anyone else express them.
Lorenzo is very good at connecting the dots (historical and modern) that many others miss.
We also need to remember that a reasonably open and free marketplace offers a rigorous profit and loss exam system all by itself in the private sector. This is further aided by wiser money lending and decent court enforcement and review of contracts.
Fascinating and an education in something I'd never thought to consider as always!
A small typo ...
"turned out to be a week reed ... (Almost everything is a week reed...)" Should be "weak" reed?
Fixed, ta, and glad you liked the post.
One question I have is: why the novelty-sized erection among western elites for mass immigration? (You may have answered this in another essay.)
I have an essay coming out on Helen Dale’s that considers that. This essay by me touches on it.
https://www.lorenzofromoz.net/p/the-migration-scam
LOL yes I thought so. Thanks.
If you were a Roman businessman who reinvested your profit to grow your business, what would happen to you? You would become a target for a Roman emperor to have you arrested and executed on trumped up charges and take your fortune to finance the state.
If you were a Chinese businessman, you had low status. You could spend your excess profits on growing your business to become a richer low status person or you could buy land and become a higher status landowner, or if you had a son with the aptitude you could invest in education for him in the hopes of becoming an even higher status mandarin.
Ditto for the Italian Renaissance merchants. They could invest their profits increasing capacity and driving down profits to the ruination of the trade, or they could use them to gain status as patrons of the arts, or to buy influence with the Church and local politicians, gaining status this way.
There was no reason to reinvest profits to accumulate capital until doing so became connected to status. In this post I argue that it was the introduction of gunpowder into the multistate European states system that ultimately led to capitalism and from that to the scientific revolution and cheap energy.
https://mikealexander.substack.com/p/a-take-on-how-the-scientific-revolution
I would note that China was using large amounts of coal during the Middle Ages but did not industrialize. China was a single polity. There was no multistate system involved in frequent wars as in Europe and so no need to scale up military action and to resort to capitalism to pay for it.
Actually, Roman fortunes were generally rather safer than that. Political activity could make you are target, but there were plenty of multi-generational wealthy families.
You have to be careful about status. Merchants had notionally low status in Tokugawa Japan. It did not stop the creation of very long lasting merchant families and firms. Of course, one of the advantages of Japan was the daimyo were a form of competitive jurisdictions.
The China suffered somewhat from the curse of unity is clearly true. A recent study concluded that China was the most technologically dynamic in the period between the end of Han and the rise of Sui. A major part of the issue in China is that ruling Dynasties became suspicious of any connections that extended across regions.
Medieval European Christendom evolved in the way it did because of competitive jurisdictions and the suppression of kin groups.
The use of boycotts to protect those engaged in commerce was more common than people realise. The Hansaeatic League was partly organised to provide such mutual support. It was clearly, an important feature of caste systems.
It is much like the distinctions between legal and functional property rights: it is easy overstate the gulf between them.
The claim that DOGE is performing audits sounds very 1984 to me. In the case of USAID, they at most collected a few anecdotes and some of those weren't even USAID. I have yet to hear of anything close to an actual audit.